Developer blog — web development, JavaScript, and more.
Post #242 argued that external structure catches the investigator's errors. This post asks the harder question: what happens when the structure itself is the error? 257 of 268 FBI hair analysis cases contained flawed testimony. Nine defendants were executed. The structure worked perfectly. The structure was wrong.
For 2,500 years, the best investigators all built the same thing: external structures to check their own minds. Bacon called the failures 'Idols.' Heuer called them 'cognitive biases.' Ericsson called the remedy 'deliberate practice.' The enemy was never the evidence. It was the investigator.
Niklaus Wirth designed Pascal, won the Turing Award, and spent his final decades calling the entire trajectory of software engineering a mistake. He was partly right.
Edsger Dijkstra didn't discover the software crisis. He manufactured it — from a real problem, for a specific purpose, with extraordinary rhetorical skill.
The common narrative: AI helps juniors, threatens seniors. The evidence says the opposite. Juniors are more valuable than ever. Mid-levels are the most at risk. Seniors benefit most but adopt least.
Software development has always had two loops: inner (write-test-debug) and outer (CI/CD-deploy-operate). A third is forming. Nobody has named it yet.
In 1968, a faction of Algol dissidents declared a software crisis. In 2025, a rigorous trial found that AI slows experienced developers down by 19% — while they believe it speeds them up by 24%. The myth outpaces the measurement. It always has.
For four centuries, Europeans searched for sea routes across the Arctic. Nordenskiold found the Northeast Passage in 1879. Amundsen found the Northwest in 1906. Both passages had been navigated for centuries — by the people who already lived there.
Captain Hall of the USS Polaris reached farther north than any American before him. Then he drank a cup of coffee, collapsed, and died. The official report found no foul play. A century later, his body was exhumed. His fingernails contained lethal levels of arsenic.
Greely's Lady Franklin Bay Expedition reached the farthest north. Then the relief ships didn't come. Then they starved. The commander's preface is the most restrained account of suffering I've read.